The screenwriter of "Man Jiang Hong" and "as strong as a Rock" talks about screen photo: infringing upon the intellectual property rights of producers and creators

February 17,"Manjianghong""solid as a rock" screenwriter, Peking University professor @ Peking University Chen Yu shared his views on screen photography: "Now from the regulations, it is clear that dynamic video can not be stolen, as for stolen pictures, there seems to be no clear provisions." However, from a legal point of view, it should be equivalent to banning dynamic video, because it violates the intellectual property rights of producers and creators, and from a physical point of view, dynamic video is not composed of 24 pictures per second."

It is reported that in 2023,"Manjianghong" and other Spring Festival films also jointly issued a statement of "refusing to steal photos."

Chen Yu's full text reads as follows:

There has been a lot of discussion about "theft" in the past two days, and I have thought about it for a while.

Let's look at two situations first.

__"Hot and Hot", Jia Ling spent a year, lost a hundred pounds, the whole process painstakingly avoided all public appearances, even the premiere and publicity photos dare not have, just to let the audience cry out "wow" when watching the movie.

As a result, in the first scene, the audience stole photos and posted on Weibo. Brother brought benefits to you. Take a look at Jia Ling's thinness. Hey.

  • Suspense film, your IQ is high, you are ready to reason excitedly, go to the toilet before the movie starts, don't delay time to see a circle of friends, see the picture sent by Tony teacher downstairs of your house: this is the person, the protagonist's elementary school classmate is the big boss.

Obviously, these two examples show that piracy is problematic, at least on a moral level.

A lot of friends will take pictures of dishes taken at restaurants in Little Red Book to compare: I paid for it, the dishes were bought, what happened to taking a photo?

But there's a difference here. The main value of the dish is that it's physically eaten by you, and what it looks like is only a secondary added value. But movies are different. Its value is the value of information. Pirates spread information, which deprives those who have not yet learned the information of the fun of the information process. It's a little like sucking the juice off the surface of a vinegar ball and leaving it to you.

This is true on the moral level. Look at the legal level. There are two angles here. One is the current legal provisions, and the other is that the law has not yet stipulated, but what is the legal principle?

Now from the regulations, it is clear that dynamic video can not be stolen, as for stolen pictures, there seems to be no clear provisions. However, from a legal point of view, it should be equivalent to banning dynamic video, because it infringes the intellectual property rights of producers and creators, and from a physical point of view, dynamic video is not composed of 24 pictures per second?

When we judge whether we should do something, the order is law-jurisprudence-morality. We can only say, first ponder according to this order?

Dude said what nonsense, moral level or too high, too high on the line. Then we will return to the simple low or low, cow B or not level.

Do we really think that watching a movie earlier than others, taking a picture, sending it out of the cinema, is a pretty high thing, and worth telling the world on social media in the circle of friends?

We might as well decide whether it is better to eat out or eat at home after watching the movie.