"Huo Qubing" caused controversy. Why can't historical dramas pass the test of historical fans?

< span>" Huo to Disease "< / span >

at the age of 17, he led the soldiers to break Huo's disease of Xiongnu for the first time, but he was a frontier fortress soldier in the first 20 episodes of a TV series.

recently, the TV series "Huo to the Disease" was caught in controversy because of its adaptation, which was boycotted by Huo's fans before it was broadcast, and set off a debate on the Internet.

< strong > "Huo Quan Disease" was boycotted by historical fans, and Guanwei: there is no "n corner love" < / strong >

Huo Quan is a famous general of the Western Han Dynasty, and the nephew of Wei Qing and Wei Zifu was appointed school captain of Luoyao by Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty at the age of 17. He went to war with Wei Qing twice in Monan, and at the age of 19 he was appointed a general of Tuo, leading the army to occupy the evil king and Xiutu in the Hexi region, laying the foundation for the Han Dynasty to open up the road to the Western regions. After the official to Da Sima, but died young, 24-year-old died of illness.

Young general, legendary hero, there are also many film and television works about Huo Qifan, such as "Emperor Han Wu" and "son of Heaven" and so on. "Huo to the Disease" has always been a project that director Zhang Jian wants to do. Four or five years ago, he invited his son Zhang Ruoyun to star, but Zhang Ruoyun refused because "the story of the natural god of war could not convince him." Later, the script was adjusted to increase Huo's life as a soldier in the border fortress before he became a general.

in 2016, filming of the TV series "Huo to the Disease" began, with Zhang Ruoyun playing the leading role. The show has not been scheduled for broadcast since it was killed in July last year, but recently it has angered Huo's sick fans because of the flowers.

fans of Huo Quan believe that there are many historical mistakes in the flowers. For example, Huo Quan was born in a legendary family. Emperor Wudi of the Han Dynasty was an uncle, Queen Wei Zifu was an aunt, and General Wei Qing was an uncle, but in the play he became a general from a frontier fortress.

in addition, Huo Quan not only has emotional entanglements with many female characters, but also seems to be rescued by the female master after being captured by Xiongnu. Moreover, Huo Quan's illness has a "foe and friend" relationship with the prince of Xiongnu.

Huo Quan's fans believe that this is a "fabrication" and is not in line with his historical record of treating Xiongnu as mortal enemies.

the official microblog of the TV series "Huo to the Disease" immediately posted a Weibo response, saying that there was no plot in which "Huo was captured by Xiongnu and later saved by a woman." I hope everyone will discuss it calmly and rationally.

but the response did not quell the controversy. Huo Qudi fans believe that there are many common sense mistakes in the play, such as Emperor Wudi of the Han Dynasty wearing a yellow dragon robe, Huo went to war with illness, and Emperor Wudi of the Han Dynasty was still in harmony. What disappoints them most is that the creator of the TV series once said that he would respect history and never tamper with it, but now he hangs the banner of historical dramas to show Huo's private life and love history.

on the afternoon of the 12th, the official WeChat of "Huo to Disease" responded again, clarifying eight points, including no change in the identity and setting of historical figures, Huo Qizi never became friends with anyone on the Xiongnu side, and there was no rumored plot of "N-angle love". At the same time, the official account name was changed to "Huo Quan Disease official WeChat." But this does not seem to convince Huo's fans.

Huo Quan fan Yao Yao told Chinanews.com that she believes that the degree of adaptation of historical dramas lies in respecting history, and where there are clear records in history books, we must respect history. When the history is blank, it can be created on its own according to the historical environment. The story of Huo's illness is already the best script, and some characters can be added to the adaptation, but it is not to erase the traces of historical figures. After

, excited fans want to report the TV series. Yao Yao also thought about it, but after thinking calmly, he still felt that he had to wait for the play to release a flower. After all, the flower is also short now. "our 'report' is not to ban him, but to change his name." Yao Yao said that from the beginning to the end, their demand is to change the name of the play to add "pure fiction", hoping that the play will no longer bind Huo to the sick name consumption.

< strong > Why can't historical dramas always pass the historical fan level? < / strong >

the controversy is growing. On Weibo, there are still many people calling for the TV series to be renamed. Some history fans worry that after the TV series is broadcast, many people may think that Huo Qifu is of grass-roots origin and that he has a quadrangular love, which is tarnishing the hero.

however, some people think that the TV series has not yet been broadcast, according to the brain supplement "tear" the play side, this is not rigorous. Others retort that few people regard TV dramas as history, which confuses historical facts with literary and artistic creation.

in fact, there has been a dispute between history fans and TV series for a long time. In 2012, the Tang Dynasty film and television adaptation of Tonghua's novel "the Ballad of the Desert" was boycotted by history fans.

Historical fans listed several "crimes" of the "Great Desert Ballad", such as Huo went to the disease to fake his death, followed Princess Xiongnu to run away, wrote about the Xiongnu's invasion of the Han Dynasty as the Han Dynasty's invasion of the Xiongnu, and began to resist it on Tieba, Weibo and other platforms. Later, the Great Desert Ballad began to be revised for as long as two years. The title of the play was changed to "Strange fate in the Wind", all the names and place names were changed, and Huo went to illness and changed to Wei Wuji.

Yao Yao is also aware of this. In her view, the Great Desert Ballad is a complete insult to national heroes, but after it changes the names of all relevant historical figures and has nothing to do with Huo's illness, there will be no conflict.

in 2017, the film "embroidered Spring Dao 2," starring Zhang Zhen and Yang Mi, was also questioned by historical fans after its release. Some people think that the interpretation of Emperor Chongzhen in Xiuchun Dao 2 deviates from the historical facts. Emperor Chongzhen is very diligent, bad women do not listen to the play, he pays attention to integrity, will not kneel to Wei Zhongxian, the relationship between Chongzhen and the apocalypse is also very deep, and so on.

in early 2018, Fan Bingbing's TV series Legend of Ba Qing (also known as "winning the World") was also boycotted by historical fans for matching Qin Shihuang Yi Zheng with the widow Ba Qing. They believe that the play has discredited Qin Shihuang into a violent rapist, relying on the heroine to build the Great Wall and even sharing the world with the heroine, which is a discredit and distortion of historical figures.

< strong > History fans are also classified, and there is also a chain of disdain? < / strong >

at this point, I have to mention history fans.

similar to star fans, there are also many types of history fans: only fans, club fans and CP fans. Some people like the Han Dynasty, some people like the Ming Dynasty, there are personal fans, such as Huo to illness, Wei Qing fans, as well as husband and wife fans, monarch fans and so on. On the list of historical topics on Weibo, Huo Qifan ranks at the top, while Zhou Yu, Wei Qing, Zhuge Liang, Zhu Di, Qin Shihuang and so on can also be said to be "traffic takers."

according to an article in Southern Metropolis Weekly, history fans have a common characteristic as fans, that is, fanaticism. Compared with star fans, they like to fight, read books, or read books at the same time.

Yao Yao is 20 years old this year and is still a student. In 2014, she accidentally searched Huo's name and was attracted by his experience. Before that, she was a historical idiot who didn't even know the order of the ancient dynasties, but because she fell in love with Huo's illness, she began to buy books and read books to understand the history of his time.

for this reason, she once went to the graveyard where Huo was sick to worship alone and visited the ruins of Weiyang Palace and museums. She also posted on Weibo that her biggest regret is that she was not born during the Jianyuan period of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty.

to her, Huo Qifan is a "love bean in ancient times". The only difference is that he is long gone.

Why do you like an ancient man? Yao Yao believes that Huo's illness represents a word: miracle.

"he is an undefeated and unique young general, and he is also a teenager with his own interests. Filial piety, unruly, frivolous, brave, impulsive, smart. "

the love of Huo's illness has also changed her hobbies and lifestyle, making her quieter, less impetuous and more patient with her relatives and friends.

unlike Yao Yao, some people think that history fans are their ideal intergenerational sustenance and the combination of interest, knowledge structure and aesthetics with a certain period of history. Some scholars also believe that fans are a modern concept, like a historical figure or a certain period of history has become a fan, it may be far away from rationality.

if you like an ancient man, do you like your history or your imagination?

Yao Yao doesn't think it's contradictory. She said that there are actually many historical records about Huo's illness, and he remembers everything he does very clearly. "it's not much different, I think, to speculate a person's character based on his behavior."

"he was like the hope of life, freeing me from my previous aimless life." Yao Yao said. (some names in the article are aliases)